Judicial Review on the Decisions of the Specific Authorities of the Administrative Hearing in Iran and Lebanon

Fallazadeh, Ali Mohamad; Alidadzadeh, Roholla

doi:10.22059/jcl.2019.278901.633825

Judicial Review on the Decisions of the Specific Authorities of the Administrative Hearing in Iran and Lebanon

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

¹ Assistant Professor, Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Allameh Tabataba’i, Tehran, Iran

² Ph.D. Student in Public law, Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Allameh Tabataba’i, Tehran, Iran

10.22059/jcl.2019.278901.633825

Abstract

Administrative judgment is functionally very similar in Iran and Lebanon. In the highest level of administrative judgment in these two countries, there are two authorities of “Administrative Justice Court” and “the Council of the State”. In both countries, in lower levels of administrative hearing, the specific authorities have special positions and do the dispute resolution and decision-making in various subjects of administrative affairs. These authorities have plenty of types and they do not follow a single judicial law order. The legal system of Iran encounters a chaos in the field of judicial review of “Administrative Justice Court” in the way that sometimes the general courts are the ultimate authority to hear the contest of awards and sometime the “Administrative Justice Court” does so. The AJC does not take a unique judicial procedure in processing the verdicts of these authorities and a divergence of decisions is observed in this regard.
The main purpose of this research is to compare the judicial review on the decisions of the specific authorities of administrative hearing in these two legal systems. The methodology of the research is comparative and descriptive- analytical. The most important finding of this study shows thatthe “Administrative Justice Court” of Iran unlike the “Council of the State” of Lebanon, has not accepted its competency about all the specific authorities of administrative hearings.

Keywords

20.1001.1.1735496.1398.10.2.12.1

Main Subjects

Public law

References

Imami, M. and Ostovarsangary, K. ( 2012) Administrative Law, Vol 2, Publication: Mizan, Iran
Imami, M. and mousavi, N. ( 2004) Theoretical Foundations of Quasi-judicial Authorities and their Position in Iranian Law ", Social and Human Sciences Journal,Course 21, No 2: Shiraz University Publications.
Delavari, M. ( 2013) Organization and Administrative Justice Court Procedure Law in the current legal order , Aavishan-e-shomal Publications.
A series of Judiciary Sentences of branches of Administrative Justice Court (2014) Judiciary Press and Publishing Center, March 2013.
A series of Judiciary Sentences of branches of Administrative Justice Court (2014) Judiciary Press and Publishing Center, January 2012.
A series of Judiciary Sentences of branches of Administrative Justice Court (2014) Judiciary Press and Publishing Center, March & April 2012.
Deputy of Education and Research of Administrative Justice Court (2011) Jurisdiction of the Administrative Justice Court and Supreme Court judgments, The official newspaper of the country.
Nehatkhah, M. (2010) Law of the Administrative Justice Court, Jungle Publications.
Naimi, E. (2008) Jurisdiction of the Administrative Justice Court in relation to Public and Non-governmantal Institutions, A series of articles in Administrative Justice Court Conference: Jurisdiction and Administrative Procedure: Open University.

10. Hadavand, M. (2009) Comparative Administrative Law, Vol 1, Samt Publications.

11. Hadavand, M. and Aghaee Tough, M. (2009) Exclusive Administrative Courts in the light of Fair Trial Principles and Procedures (Iranian Law and Comparative Study), Khorsandi Publications.

12. Vaezi, M. (2008) Role of the Administrative Justice Court in the Legal Administrative Procedure, Journal of Legal Studies, Course 1, N 3: Shiraz University.

المراجع العربیة

ابراهیم البدوی، اسماعیل(2015)، القضاء الاداری دراسة مقارنة اسس تنظیم الرقابة القضائیة علی اعمال الدارة، الطبعة الاولی، الناشر مکتبة الوفاء القانونیة- اسکندریة
الجامعه اللبنانی، مرکز الابحاث و الدراسات فی المعلومات القانونیه، قرارات مجلس الشوری الدوله اللبنانی
الجمهوریة اللبنانیة، المجلس الدستوری الکتاب السنوی( 2012)، المجلد 6 - " قوة القضیة المحکوم بها للقررات الصادرة عن المجلس الدستوری و اثراها علی قررات مجلس شوری الدولة قرار مجلسی القضایا رقم 672 " طارق مجذوب ، منشورات مجلس الدستوری، 80 تا 87
الجمهوریه اللبنانی، المجلس الدستوری الکتاب السنوی(2013)، المجلد7 ، " مفاعیل قرارات المجلس الدستوری، ماده 70 من نظام مجلس الشوری الدوله و عدم احقاق الحق الداری" خلیل سعید ابو رجیلی،منشورات مجلس الدستوری، 146 تا 155
الجمهوریه اللبنانی، المجلس الدستوری الکتاب السنوی(2014)، المجلد 8، " افکار حول اللجنه دات الصفه القضاییه و قرار المجلس الدستوری رقم 6/ 2014" طارق المجذوب، 208 تا 223
عبدالوهاب، محمد رفعت(2005)، القضاء الاداری، الکتاب الاول( دو جلد)، المنشورات الحلبی الحقوقی
مرقص، بول و نجم شکرالله، میرای(2014)، المجلس الدستوری اللبنانی فی القانون و الاجتهاد، منشورات مجلس الدستوری
نعمة اسماعیل، عصام، محاضرات فی القضا الاداری، الجامعه اللبنانی، کلیه الحقوق و العلوم السیاسیه و الاداریه