A Comparative Study between the Status of the Rights of Minorities in the Iranian Charter on Citizens' Rights and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Minorities

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Azarbaijan Shahid Madani University, Tabriz, Iran

2 L.L.M in International Law, Allameh Tabataba'i University (ATU), Tehran, Iran

Abstract

The topic of minorities rights is one of the blatant manifestations of human rights, which has been considered by the national and international legal systems. Protection of minorities rights is to be done in legislative form and through the legal documents and non-legislative form. A comparative analogy between the substance of the UN Declaration on Persons belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities (1992) and the Iranian Charter on Citizens' Rights (2016) as non-obligatory documents, may picture the panorama of the minorities rights in the two mentioned systems. The comparison reveals that the Charter coincided with the international standards mentioned in the declaration through considering particularly the non-discrimination principle, cultural participation and diversity mentioned in the declaration. It should be mentioned that the Charter has not considered some affirmative obligations of the government in protecting the survival of minorities and non-considering the prohibition and punishment of the minority rights activists. Still the Charter is much more developed than the declaration in some fields like considering the prohibition of hatred speech. The noticeable compatibility of the Charter substance with the declaration reveals that the Charter is implicitly impressed by the declaration.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. 1. Ahmadi Tabataba’i, S.M.R, (2009), Civil Rights with an Emphasis on the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Iran, Journal of First Line, Islamic Revolution Approach, no. 8, pp. 3-18 (in Persian)

    2. Akhavan, Monireh, (2016), Minorities Rights in International Law & Islamic Republic of Iran, Journal of Women Rights Protection Studies, no. 8, pp. 47-70. (in Persian)

    3. Eslami, Reza & Kamalvand, M.M., (2014), Freedom of gatherings in Iranian law system in the light of International Human Rights setting, Journal of International Law, no. 50, pp. 187-222. (in Persian)

    4. Beygzadeh, Ebrahim & Majdzadeh, Ghazal (2012), Modern Government, Cultural Rights of the indigenous people and the minorities, Journal of Legal Research, no. 8, pp. 279-314. (in Persian)

    5. Parvin, Kheyrollah & Sepehrifar, Sima, (1995), Minorities’ Rights in Constitution, Journal of Islamic Human Rights Studies, no. 6, pp. 73-96 (in Persian)

    6. Rostami, Sorayya, (2013), Civil Rights and legitimate freedoms, Journal of Islamic Fiq’h and Law Bases, no. 1, pp. 141-162. (in Persian)

    7. Zamani, S.GH. (2005) Minorities Protection in Human Rights Universal Documents, Journal of law & Policy Studies, no. 16, pp. 145-187. (in Persian)

    8. Salahi, S. & Bhadori Jahromi, A. (2012), Constitutional Constructions of Islamic republic of Iran & Republic of Iraq, A Comparative Study, Journal of Comparative Law, no. 2, pp.65-82. (in Persian)

    9. Abbasi, B. & Ja’fari, M. (2011), A comparative inquiry to the qualifications of voters and elected in the election system of Iran and Malaysia parliaments, Journal of Comparative Law, no. 2, pp. 115-132. (in Persian)

    10. Azizi, Sattar, (2015), Minority Protection in International Law, The SD Institute of Law Research & Study, Tehran. (in Persian)

    11. Islamic Human Rights Commission of Iran, (2012), Research & Study Affairs, Defining the definition and scope of cultural rights in international human rights measures.

    12. Islamic Human Rights Commission of Iran, (2013), Research & Study Affairs, Lingual minorities’ rights.

    13. Mazhari, Mohammad, (2016), A Consideration in the Process of City and Village Councils in Iran and France, Journal of Comparative Law, no. 2, pp.725-752. (in Persian)

    1. Alam, Aftab, (2015 (, »Minority Rights under International Law«, Journal of the Indian Law Institute, vol. 57, No. 3, pp: 376-400.
    2. Burch Elias, Stella, (2010), »Regional Minorities, Immigrants, and Migrants: The Reframing of Minority Language Rights in Europe«, Berkeley Journal of International Law, vol. 28, No. 1, pp. 261-312.
    3. ECMI, (European Centre for Minority Issues), 2013, »Communities in Kosovo: A guidebook for professionals working with communities in Kosovo«.
    4. Gagliardone, Iginio and Others, (2015), »Countering Online Hate Speech«, UNESCO.
    5. Jabareen, Yousef T., (2012), » Redefining Minority Rights: Successes and Shortcomings of the U.N. Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples«, University of California, Davis, Vol. 18:1, pp. 119-161.
    6. Kovačević, Dragana, (2011), » International Minority Protection System«, Ethnicity Research Center, Belgrade, pp.1-13.
    7. Kugelmann, Dieter, (2007), »The protection of minorities and indigenous peoples respecting cultural diversity«, Max Planck yearbook of united nation law, vol.11, pp233-263.
    8.  Kumar Das, Jatindra, (2016), » Human Rights Law and Practice«, PHI Learning Pvt. Ltd.
    9.  Macklem, Patrick, (2008), »Minority Rights in International Law«, International Journal of Constitutional Law, Vol. 6, Issue 3-4, pp.531-552.
    10. Mcgonagle, T., (2008), »Minority Rights and Freedom of Expression: A Dynamic Interface«, Ph.D Thesiss, University Of Amsterdam.
    11. Mendel, Toby, (2010), »Hate Speech Rules under International Law«, Executive Director, Center for Law and Democracy.
    12.  O'Connell, Rory, (2006), »the Right to Participation of Minorities and Irish Travelers«,Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism, Vol. 6, pp2-29.
    13.  Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), (2010), Minority Rights: International Standards and Guidance for Implementation (HR/PUB/10/3).
    14. Papoutsi, Emilia, (2014), »Minorities under International Law: How protected they are? «, Journal of Social Welfare and Human Rights, Vol. 2, No. 1, 305-345.
    15.  Pentassuglia, Gaetano, (2002), »Minorities in International Law, Council of Europe Publishing«, Germany.
    16.    Petričušić, Antonija, (2005), »the Rights of Minorities in International Law: Tracing Developments in Normative Arrangements of International Organizations«, Croatian International Relations Review, Vol. 11, No.39/38, pp: 1-23.
    17.  Thomas White, Benjamin, (2011), The Emregence of Minorities in Middle East, Edinburgh University Press.
    18. Thornberry, Patrick, (2012), »Some Controversies in the Drafting of the Declaration: A Personal Recollection«, presentation delivered in the occasion of the 5th session of the UN forum on minority issues.
    19. UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), (1998) ,»Minority Rights«, Fact Sheet, No.18 (Rev.1)
    20.  Vijapur, Abdulrahim P., (2006), » International Protection of Minority Right«, International Studies, vol. 4, pp: 367-394.
    21.  Wheatley, Steven, (2005), Democracy, Minorities and International Law, Cambridge University Press.
    22.  Yupsanis, Athanasios, (2013), »Article 27 of the ICCPR Revisited«, Hague yearbook of International Law, vol. 26, pp: 358-409.

     

    Documents

    1. Iranian Charter of Civil Rights, 2016.
    2. Declaration on the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities
    3. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)
    4. Human Rights Committee, General Comment No 23: The Rights of Minorities (Art. 27), UN Doc. CCPR/C /21/Rev.1/Add.5, 8 April 1994.
    5. UNESCO's work on endangered languages
    6. UNESCO’s Recommendation on the Status of Teachers (1966)
    7.  The International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD), (1969).
    8. PCIJ doc. Greco-Bulgarian Communities, Advisory Opinion, )1930(.
Comparative Law Review
Volume 9, Issue 1
Spring & Summer
April 2018
Pages 203-230

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics