Comparative Law Review

Comparative Law Review

Study of protection of citizens’ privacy during Covid-19 period with ‎emphasis on data processing‏ ‏‎(Comparative study of U.S., China, ‎France, and Iran law)‎

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
Mohsen Safari 1
Sajjad Ghasemi 2
1 Department of Private and Islamic Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, ‎Tehran, Iran‎
2 Department of Private Law, Department of Private and Islamic Law, Faculty of Law and Political ‎Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran‎
10.22059/jcl.2023.352730.634451
Abstract
Necessity of confrontation with coronavirus pandemic has moved governments toward taking a variety of actions in the field of defeating coronavirus (including data processing) which have influenced different aspects of life of citizens and caused many legal challenges in relation to the privacy of citizens in the time of corona outbreak. Comparative and descriptive-analytical method study of legal frameworks governing the right to privacy in the U.S., China, France, and Iran reveals that governments on the basis of special authorizations have taken actions during the pandemic which would be considered as violations to privacy in normal circumstances. French legal system has protected privacy in a centralized and transparent manner and based on accountability and responsibility which mostly is due to the existence of a controller entity. China law because of comprehensive legislations and regulations and citizens’ trust in legal and political systems faced few challenges. Iranian law despite the legal and jurisprudential foundations for the protection of privacy is faced with legislation lack and absence of a controller and accountable entity for data processing, and in U.S. law there have been serious legal challenges because of the dual nature of federal and state system and lack of a holistic approach toward the right to privacy and lack of a supervisor entity on data processing. Furthermore, courts have limited the scope of the government's authority in dealing with the coronavirus in relation to privacy matters. In China and France, the government's entry into the field of privacy has been more serious, with the difference that transparency and compliance with the principles of citizen's rights have been in a better state in France. On the other hand, in American law, the least invasion of privacy has been done. In Iran, the lack of clear laws and guidelines can cause privacy concerns.
Keywords
Data processing
privacy
‎Corona
personal data.‎
Subjects

  1. English

    1. Bandelier, Silvia; Dressel, Charlotte; Lanier, Clément; Steger-Kicinski, Arthur (2022). Retour sur le passe vaccinal: libre disposition de son corps et consentement aux soins, La Revue des droits de l’homme, May 2022.
    2. Beverley-Smith, Huw; Ohly, Ansgar; Lucas-Schloetter, Agne (2005). Privacy, Property and Personality; Civil Law Perspectives on Commercial Appropriation, New York: Cambridge university press
    3. Black, Campbell M. A. (1968), Black’s law dictionary, West publishing co.
    4. Bradford, Laura; Aboy, Mateo; Liddell, Kathleen (2020). COVID-19 Contact Tracing Apps: A Stress Test for Privacy, the GDPR and Data Protection Regimes, Journal of Law and the Biosciences, Paper No. 23/2020
    5. Cole, Jared P. & Swendiman, Kathleen S. (2014). Mandatory Vaccinations: Precedent and Current Laws, Washington: Congressional Research Service
    6. Cornu, Gérard (2018). Vocabulaire juridique, Paris: Presses Universitaires de France
    7. Cortez, Elif Kiesow (2021). Data Protection Around the World; Privacy Laws in Action, The Hague: T.M.C. ASSER PRESS, 2021
    8. Cudd, Ann E. & Navin, Mark C. (2018). Core Concepts and Contemporary Issues in Privacy, Springer International Publishing
    9. Duan, W. & Qin, T. (2022). The Impact of China’s Legal System on Public Health and Quality of Life during the COVID-19 Pandemic: An Empirical Study, Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, 19
    10. Guide sur l’article 8 de la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme; Droit au respect de la vie privée et familiale, du domicile et de la correspondence, (2022). Conseil de l’Europe/Cour européenne des droits de l’homme,
    11. Guinchard, Serge & Debard, Thierry, (2018). Lexique des termes juridiques 2017-2018, Paris: Dalloz
    12. Jingchun, Cao (2005), Protecting the Right to Privacy in China, Victoria University of Wellington Law Review 36(3)
    13. Kostka, Genia& Habich-Sobiegalla, Sabrina (2022). In times of crisis: Public perceptions toward COVID-19 contact tracing apps in China, Germany, and the United States. New Media & Society
    14. Liu, Jun& Zhao, Hui (2021). Privacy lost: Appropriating surveillance technology in China’s fight against COVID-19, Business Horizons, Vol. 64, Issue 6
    15. Martin, E. A., (1997). Oxford dictionary of law, New York: Oxford University Press
    16. Mbongo, Pascal (2012). The French Privacy Law, The Right to Privacy in the Light of Media Convergence, Germany: de Gruyter
    17. Mitchell, Mann; Mitchell, Peta; Foth, Marcus (2022). Between surveillance and technological solutionism: A critique of privacy-preserving apps for COVID-19 contact tracing, New Media and Society
    18. Nass, SJ; Levit, LA; Gostin, LO (2009). Beyond the HIPAA Privacy Rule: Enhancing Privacy, Improving Health Through Research, Washington: National Academies Press
    19. Peikoff, Amy L. (2008). Beyond Reductionism: Reconsidering the Right to Privacy, NYU Journal of Law and Liberty, Vol. 3, No. 1
    20. Pernot-Leplay, Emmanuel (2020), China's Approach on Data Privacy Law: A Third Way Between the U.S. and the E.U.? 8 PENN. ST. J.L. & INT'L AFF. 49
    21. Rigaux, François (1992). La vie privée: Une liberté parmi les autres, Bruxelles: Larcier
    22. Scassa, Teresa; Millar, Jason; Bronson, Kelly (2020). Privacy, Ethics, and Contact-tracing Apps, Vulnerable: The Law and Policy of COVID-19, University of Ottawa Press
    23. Simko, Lucy; Chang, Jack; Jiang, Maggie; Calo, Ryan; Roesner, Franziska; Tadayoshi Kohno. (2022). COVID-19 Contact Tracing and Privacy: A Longitudinal Study of Public Opinion, Digital Threats, 3, Article 25
    24. Vitalis, André (2009). Informatique et libertés: une histoire de trente ans, Hermès, La Revue 2009/1 (n° 53), pages 137 à 143
    25. Wang, Limin& Yang, Lixin (eds) (1997), The Law of the Rights of The Person, Beijing: The Press of Laws
    26. Warren, Samuel D. & Brandeis, Louis D., (1890). The Right to Privacy, Harvard Law Review, Vol. 4, No. 5., pp. 193-220.
    27. Wiederkehr, Georges (2019). Code civil annoté, Paris: Dalloz
    28. Wu, J.; Wang, J.; Nicholas, S.; Maitland, E.; Fan, Q. (2020). Application of Big Data Technology for COVID-19 Prevention and Control in China: Lessons and Recommendations, Journal of medical Internet research, 22(10)
    29. Yue Yang; Baik, Jeeyun; Ahn, Soyun; Jang, Eugene (2020). Tracing Digital Contact Tracing: Surveillance Technology and Privacy Rights During COVID-19 in China, South Korea, and the United States, SSRN Electronic Journal
Comparative Law Review
Volume 15, Issue 1
Espring & Summer
July 2024
Pages 93-119